James Kalb
Is “discrimination” merely negative?
Many people claim discrimination is merely negative: “white,” for example, means “not colored,” where “colored” refers to those whose exclusion constitutes “white” as a category. On such a view discrimination has to do with artificial categories. There are academics who make even sex a social construction.
Such claims are evidently trivial or false. It is … More ...
Bach Vespers as the Twilight of the Gods
I recently went to “Bach Vespers” at Holy Trinity Lutheran Church here in New York. The music was good, the ceremony dignified, the physical surroundings beautiful and fitting, the people highly presentable in a high-class respectable Northern European serious-minded style.
I won’t go back, because all those fine things were made part of the rites … More ...
Bacon in the fire
Real Physics, the weblog of an Aristotelian physics PhD, has an interesting post on Climategate as a manifestation of Baconian science—that is, of “science” oriented toward control rather than truth.
My take on the problem is that modern scientific thought emphasizes experimental verification and tries to pare down references to things that can’t be … More ...
Corrosive objections from the Rust Belt
Something I wrote, an analysis of liberalism, libertarianism, and conservatism, was enough to provoke a libertarian blogger (“larryniven”) to murder fantasies. I decided to address his concerns, but our exchange went nowhere. So I decided to reconstruct it, along with a short side exchange with a mainstream social liberal from Australia, into the … More ...
Rusty Reno’s “resistance” review
R. R. Reno has a review of my book in the most recent Intercollegiate Review. He titles the review “Resistance Literature,” a phrase intended as high praise.
Diversity alert
One interest prompting my return to blogging is some writing I’ve been doing about “inclusiveness.” I’ve written various pieces on the topic, and I touched on the issue in my recent book. Now I’m trying to put my thoughts together in what may turn into a series of articles or book. I’ll be posting … More ...
Liberal identity and hipsterdom
Inclusiveness tells us that characteristics that traditionally define personal identity have no legitimate social role. If my specific identity as a man or member of a particular people is connected to my position in the world, that’s intolerable and something has to be done about it.
That can’t be the end of the story. We … More ...
Out of his depth
Does Obama’s handshake/bow to the Japanese emperor remind anyone else of a high school kid clowning for the camera in a yearbook picture?
Rulers of the world unite!
A friend sent me something he was writing on the political prospects for protectionist legislation. I sent him the following response, which I’ve edited a bit and relates to much more than protectionism:
… More ...In general, your discussion follows the interest-group, competing political party, voter sovereignty model of political life in a modern democracy.
I sometimes